Power News We love to talk!

SEP 27 2016

Solar sector gets the short shift in hunt for cheaper power

  • Economic Times, ET Bureau / Hyderabad
  • Created: Tue 27th SEP 2016

The solar power sector faces a hurdle in meeting its ambitious growth target as cash-strapped distribution companies (discoms) are purchasing cheaper electricity from the exchanges and via e-auction.

Some discoms are simply resorting to power cuts as they cannot afford to even purchase power at low rates on the exchanges. The increase in renewable energy (RE) capacity addition has caused some solar power curtailment issues in Rajasthan and Tamil Nadu, where discoms have flouted the “must run” status of solar power, affecting developers.

Currently, power is traded at Rs 2.40 to Rs 2.50 a unit on exchanges and on e-auction platforms compared to Rs 4-Rs 5 a unit for solar power under power purchase agreements (PPAs).

Raj Prabhu, chief executive of Mercom Capital Group, said the curtailment was still not widespread, but the issue has to be addressed immediately before it hurt investor sentiments. “The problem is more pronounced in Tamil Nadu, especially in high wind energy density areas when wind and solar generation peak simultaneously. In Tamil Nadu, curtailment is mostly due to the utility opting to buy cheaper power from exchanges rather than paying Rs 7 a unit for solar (the state has signed PPAs for that rate),” he said.

R V Shahi, former power secretary, said the comparison between price of conventional power and solar power is not for total price of conventional power but only marginal cost of variable charge. “This means discoms have started considering whether they should buy under PPA thermal power at variable cost of Rs 1 (domestic coal) and Rs 2 (imported coal), which is an option, or buy solar at Rs 4 or Rs 5 a unit under must-run condition.

This consideration is not irrelevant, keeping in view the financial conditions of discoms. Simultaneously, average price of thermal power, which will operate at lower plant load factor (PLF), will also increase and further burden discoms.  Even now many generators are not getting sufficient dispatch of solar power,” he added.

Rajesh K Mediratta, director (business development), Indian Energy Exchange Limited, said there was a serious conflict from economic signals coming from framework for solar. “We pay to solar generators at feed in tariff for each unit generated. So, if preferential tariff for a RE generation is Rs 5 per unit, the discom has to pay Rs 5 for each unit of marginal generation. Whereas, marginal cost of generation is zero. Therefore, we need to apply same mechanism as Germany where RE generators sell through exchanges at zero marginal cost and get paid for green premium through government common funds. Such mechanism can only mitigate problem of discoms curtailing power from RE generators,” he said.


Rajasthan TOTAL Tamil Nadu Sri Prabhu Lingeshwara Sugar & Chemical Ltd Distribution Companies Renewable Energy Coal Wind Tariff Energy Imported Coal Mercom Capital Group Capacity Addition Power Electricity solar power Solar

Related News

  • Govt may let power plants pass on gear costs to meet green norms  Read more
  • NHPC CMD KM Singh hopeful of resumption of work of stalled 2000 MW Lower Subansiri hydro power project  Read more
  • Power minister cracks down on discoms, refuses to allow ATC loss to be passed on  Read more
  • Industry bodies express shock over decision to hold back 8 coal blocks  Read more
  • KSERC partially upholds petition filed by KPUPL against KSEBL  Read more
  • Govt may tap private sector to fill CEO posts at CIL, NHPC  Read more
  • RPT-India leads Asian cuts in Iran oil imports ahead of waiver review  Read more
  • Coming, future coal linkages for the power sector  Read more
  • Banks told to advance loans to 5,000 solar units by next March-end  Read more
  • MSME Min exploring tech to operate charkha on solar energy  Read more