Power News We love to talk!

MAR 11 2013

CEA evaluating power generation equipment from China

  • Economic Times, ET Bureau / Hyderabad
  • Created: Mon 11th MAR 2013

Notices sent to firms for information; survey aims to put to rest worries on performance

Central Electricity Authority (CEA), Indias apex power sector planning body, is evaluating the performances of power generation equipment in the country supplied by Chinese firms such as Dongfang Electric Corp. and Shanghai Electric Power Co. Ltd, three people familiar with the development said.

The survey is meant to put at rest concerns over Chinese equipment, given the strategic importance of such power projects.

Several Indian power project developers including Lanco Infratech Ltd, Reliance Power Ltd, Adani Power Ltd, CLP India Pvt. Ltd and JSW Energy Ltd have placed orders with Chinese firms. Some power plants that have used Chinese equipment have earlier run into trouble.

But as some developers that have placed orders were unwilling to provide details sought by CEA, the authority invoked the Electricity Act and issued notices asking the companies to divulge information, the people mentioned above said, all declining to be identified.

Mint couldnt ascertain the names of the companies to whom notices were served.

While spokespersons for Lanco Infratech and JSW Energy didnt respond to queries emailed on 20 February, a Reliance Power spokesperson declined to comment.

A CLP spokesperson denied receiving any such notice from CEA. "We confirm that we have never been asked for any such information and nor have been issued any notice, the CLP spokesperson said.

An Adani Group spokesperson in an emailed response said, "We have been providing information on the queries from time to time to the authorities. We have not received any queries in recent past. However, if asked we will certainly provide the requisite information.

CEAs decision follows an earlier quality audit on Chinese power equipment in 2008, which was completed without the participation of any of the Chinese companies involved.

"The equipment evaluation has been taken up by CEA. Since they were not getting the required information from some of the developers, notices were sent under the (Electricity) Act, a power ministry official, one of the three mentioned above, said.

Another power ministry official confirmed the development.

"The survey has been on for some time. We had to send notices as we were not getting the required information. Since data was not being shared, hence the Act was invoked, a top CEA official said. "We are hopeful that the evaluation will be completed in a few months. This is a sensitive topic, the data is being verified and re-verified.

Mint reported on 16 October 2008 about an earlier audit that found several problems with such machinery but stopped short of preventing power plants here from using them. The report had raised questions about the operation and maintenance of such equipment, the lack of a comprehensive quality plan and the insufficient number of Chinese engineers at site locations.

"Since onfield performance data is not available for a sufficiently long time, its difficult to conclude on the performance of Chinese equipment. Such large orders obviously raise anxiety in the planners minds, said Shubhranshu Patnaik, senior director, consulting, energy and resources at Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd, an audit and consulting firm.

There have been instances in the past when India stopped giving clearances to telecom equipment imported from China after security concerns were expressed by the ministry of home affairs and the Prime Ministers Office. India last year imposed import duty on power generation equipment that will affect Chinese manufacturers.

Queries emailed to Dongfangs and Shanghai Electrics chief representatives in India on 20 February remained unanswered. While Shanghai Electrics chief representative requested the queries to be forwarded to his personal email address, Mint couldnt confirm whether Dongfangs India representative received the emailed queries.

This evaluation comes in the backdrop of CEA preparing a list of sensitive imports such as software for electricity grids that may have security implications. The exercise is part of an effort to put in place a security framework aimed at warding off sabotage of power plants and other vital installations


"The list is ready and contains the names of hardware and software that can be tampered with. We have submitted the report, said the CEA official quoted above.

Similar lists are also being prepared at other ministries such as ports and shipping. These lists are being prepared after consultations by a committee of secretaries on the issue.


JSW Steel Ltd. Adani Power Ltd JSW Energy Ltd Electricity Act Reliance Power China Energy Central Electricity Authority Lanco Infratech Power Deloitte Adani Group Electricity India

Related News

  • RPower to knock at Appellate Tribunals door  Read more
  • Wind power: State govts to decide on tariff from smaller projects  Read more
  • Vikram Solar signs MoU with Indian Institute of Engineering Science and Technology  Read more
  • Jaya seeks Rs1,500 cr grant for wind energy project  Read more
  • India's nuclear deal with Japan should not be victim of domestic politics  Read more
  • Power transmission capacity a worry, but prices may not spike  Read more
  • RINL takes a step forward in power generation  Read more
  • Merchant power sales under lens; Coal ministry threatens to cancel allocation of coal blocks  Read more
  • Transformer replacement work on in fifth TTPS unit  Read more
  • Tesla's low-cost renewable battery could revolutionise Africa's energy supply  Read more